November 13, 2026

A good concealer can be a bit of a lifesaver, especially on those mornings when we’ve had nowhere near enough sleep! But surprisingly, concealer can also have the opposite effect, making us look more tired than we actually are! Not less! 

From choosing the wrong shade to applying a little too much, a few common mistakes can make fine lines more noticeable, dark circles appear grey and the under-eye area look dry or creased. 

So, if your concealer isn't quite working its magic, here are the mistakes worth avoiding and a few simple tricks to help you achieve a fresher, smoother, more natural-looking finish. 

 

1. You're choosing a concealer that's too light 

We've all heard the advice to go a shade or two lighter with our under-eye concealer to brighten the area. But go too light and you can end up with the exact opposite result! 

Instead of disguising dark circles, a concealer that's much paler than your natural skin tone can make the area look grey, ashy or unnaturally white. Not quite the fresh, wide-awake look we were hoping for! 

What works better? 

Choose a concealer that's close to your natural skin tone, or just slightly lighter if you want a brightening effect. 

And if you have particularly dark circles with blue or purple undertones, consider using a peach-toned colour corrector first. It helps neutralise the darkness, so you don't need to rely on layer after layer of concealer to cover it.  

The result? A much more natural-looking finish. 


2. You're applying far too much! 

Here's a mistake I'm sure plenty of us have made. You apply a little concealer, decide those dark circles are still showing, add a bit more... and then a bit more for good measure! 

Unfortunately, piling on concealer rarely makes things better. Instead, the excess product can settle into fine lines, exaggerate texture and leave the under-eye area looking heavy or cakey. 

And as our skin naturally becomes thinner and often drier with age, this can become even more noticeable. 

What works better? 

Start with a tiny amount of concealer and build only where you need extra coverage. 

For many of us, the darkest areas are around the inner corners of the eyes and along the under-eye hollow. Concentrate your concealer there rather than automatically covering the entire area beneath your eyes. 

You might be surprised by just how little product you actually need! 

 

3. You're forgetting to hydrate your under-eye area 

We spend so much time thinking about which concealer to use and how to apply it, but what about the skin underneath? Even the best concealer can struggle to look smooth and natural if our under-eye area is dry or dehydrated. And this can become even more of an issue as we age! The delicate skin around our eyes has fewer oil glands than many other areas of the face, making it more prone to dryness. The result? Concealer that clings to texture and settles into fine lines rather than blending beautifully. Eek! 

What works better? 

Before applying your makeup, use a lightweight, hydrating eye cream and allow it a few minutes to absorb. 

Look for ingredients such as hyaluronic acid, squalane and glycerin, which help attract and retain moisture, leaving the skin feeling softer and looking smoother. 

We highly recommend Pevonia Age Correction Eye Contour. Its lightweight, non-greasy formula combines marine collagen, hyaluronic acid, marine elastin, squalane and green tea extract to hydrate, depuff and smooth the delicate eye area, making it the perfect option in the morning to apply beneath makeup! 

“I love this product! The Eye Contour moisturises beautifully and softens the skin around your eyes. I would definitely recommend it to everyone.” Sam N 

Just remember not to overdo the eye cream though! Too much product, especially if it hasn't absorbed properly, can make your concealer slip or separate! 

Beauty Collective Pevonia Age Correction Eye Contour

 4. You're using the wrong concealer formula 

Here's something you need to know. Concealer you use to cover a blemish isn't necessarily the one you want under your eyes! And yes I know. You don’t want to have to purchase two concealers, but here’s why. A thick, full-coverage formula might be brilliant for hiding a spot, but beneath your eyes? It can be a completely different story! 

Very matte or heavy formulas can sometimes make fine lines and dryness more noticeable, particularly if your skin is on the mature or dehydrated side. 

What works better? 

Look for a concealer that offers good coverage but still feels lightweight and flexible on the skin. A natural or satin finish can be particularly flattering beneath the eyes. 

For example, ELES Dual Action Concealer combines medium coverage with skincare ingredients including peptides, caffeine and hyaluronic acid to help hydrate and smooth the appearance of the eye area.  

A tube of ELES Dual Action Concealer against a white background. 

“This concealer is perfection. It goes on smooth, doesn't crease, and covers dark circles completely. The concealer lasts forever because you don't need to use a lot to get full coverage.” Marwa Yates 

Or, if you prefer buildable coverage with a creamy, skin-like finish, ELES Adjustable Coverage Concealer is another great option, particularly for skin that's prone to dryness. 

ELES Adjustable Coverage Concealer with black lid on a white background

5. You're applying concealer everywhere instead of where you actually need it 

Remember the days when makeup tutorials told us to draw enormous triangles of concealer underneath our eyes? 

Well, while that technique can work for certain makeup looks, it isn't necessarily the most flattering approach for everyday makeup! 

Applying concealer across the entire under-eye area can mean covering skin that doesn't actually need any correction. And the more product you apply, the greater the chance of it settling into fine lines or looking heavy. 

What works better? 

Take a moment to look at where the darkness really is. 

You may find it's concentrated around the inner corners, or in the hollow just beneath your eyes, rather than across the entire area. 

Apply a small amount of concealer to those spots and gently blend the edges into the surrounding skin. 

A fingertip, small concealer brush or slightly damp makeup sponge can all work well. The trick is to tap and blend rather than rub or drag the product across your skin. 

And there's no need to cover every little line or shadow. A little natural skin showing through can actually make the finished result look fresher! 

concealer

6. You're using too much setting powder 

Ah, setting powder. Brilliant for keeping makeup in place, but not always so brilliant when it comes to the delicate skin beneath our eyes! 

If you've ever carefully applied your concealer, dusted powder over the top and suddenly noticed every fine line looking more obvious, you'll know exactly what I mean. 

Too much powder can absorb surface oils and moisture, leaving the under-eye area looking dry, flat or overly matte. 

And while the popular 'baking' technique can look fabulous on camera, it isn't necessarily the best approach for everyday makeup, particularly on mature or dry skin. 

What works better? 

If you need to set your concealer, use the smallest amount of finely milled powder and apply it only where necessary. 

Beauty Collective ELES HD Translucent Powder

A small, soft brush works beautifully for this. 

Before powdering, gently tap over any creases that have already formed so you're not setting them in place. 

You could also try skipping the powder altogether and see how your concealer wears. Depending on your skin and the formula you're using, you might find you don't need it! 

 

7. You're not checking your concealer in natural light 

Have you ever finished your makeup in the bathroom, thought everything looked fabulous, then caught your reflection in the car mirror and wondered what on earth happened? 

Bathroom lighting can be surprisingly misleading! 

A concealer that looks perfectly blended under warm artificial lighting might appear too pale, patchy or heavy once you step outside. 

What works better? 

Before heading out, take a quick look at your makeup near a window in natural daylight. 

Check that your concealer blends seamlessly into the surrounding skin and that there aren't any obvious lines or patches. 

If something looks a little heavy, try gently pressing a clean, slightly damp makeup sponge over the area to soften the finish rather than adding more product. 

It's such a simple little habit, but one that can make a real difference! 

 

So, if your concealer has been making you look more tired rather than less, don't be too quick to throw it away and buy something new! 

Sometimes the formula really isn't right for your skin, but often it's the little things that make the biggest difference. Choosing a more flattering shade, properly hydrating the under-eye area, applying less product or simply changing where you put it! 

Shop Products on this Blog

Pevonia Power Repair eye contour serum in bottle on a white background for end consumer use 30ml
Pevonia Age Correction Eye Contour 30ml ingredient flatlay with Marine Collagen, Marine Elastin, Green Tea, Hyaluronic Acid and Squalane

PEVONIA Age Correction Eye Contour - 30ml

$183.50

Black concealer tube with 'E lest' branding on a white background
ELES Dual Action Concealer ingredient flatlay featuring acetyl tetrapeptide-5, sodium hyaluronate, caffeine and vitamin C and E on a warm limestone surface

ELES Dual Action Concealer - 11.4g

$51.00

$51.00

Colour
ELES Adjustable Coverage Concealer with black lid on a white background
ELES Adjustable Coverage Concealer promo clip

ELES Adjustable Coverage Concealer

$64.50

$64.50

Colour
A jar of ELES brand HD Translucent Powder with the lid open, showing the powder inside.
ELES HD Translucent Powder ingredient flatlay featuring 100% mineral silica powder with quartz crystals and a ceramic dish showing light-diffusing oil-absorbing properties on a warm limestone surface

ELES HD Translucent Powder

$56.50

Your products

Add your products.